Health in the News

Read the latest health news from the various health sections of the BBC, NPR, NY Times, TIME Magazine, and others collected on Digg.com. Also don't forget to visit Medpedia at www.medpedia.com.

BBC News - Health Section

The latest health news from the health section of the BBC News.

Digg.com - Health Articles

The most recent health articles on Digg.com.

Medpedia

Medpedia - the Wikipedia for health and medicine.

New York Times - Health Section

The latest health news from the health section of the New York Times.

NPR - Health and Science

The latest health and science news from National Public Radio.

TIME - Health and Science Section

The latest health and science news from TIME, partnered with CNN.

Showing posts with label healthcare system. Show all posts
Showing posts with label healthcare system. Show all posts

Working More Reasonable Hours

Posted by Alb On 2/27/2010 11:45:00 PM 2 comments
I very recently read the following article in the Los Angeles Times, The doctor is in -- but not for long. It reports a decrease in physician work hours from an average of 55 hours/week to 51 hours/week between 1977 to 2007. The study can be found for free here: Trends in the Work Hours of Physicians in the United States by Staiger et al. in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).

Now, both articles above interpret this decrease in physician work hours as somewhat troubling, the LA Times almost "blaming" doctors for their newfound laziness (compared to teaching, law, and journalism). The study reports the decrease to be most prominent in younger physicians (defined as 45 or younger). The study concludes that this 5.7% decrease in physician work hours averaged over the 630,000 or so doctors in the 2007 workforce translates to losing about 36,000 doctors. That's pretty dramatic. 630,000 doctors to take care of over 300 million Americans is quite some feat.

I suppose I'm the devil's advocate as I find it irritating that the study concludes the decrease in physician work hours to be worrisome for the US health care. To me, it's overdue and about time for this decrease in work hours.

Let's put the hours into perspective. Assuming a 5-day workweek, 55 hours/week translates to 11 hours/day. That would be like getting to work at 6am and not leaving until 5pm, or getting to work at 7am and not leaving until 6pm, etc. Again assuming a 5-day workweek, 51 hours/week translates to just over 10 hours/day; so 6am until 4pm, or 7am until 5pm, etc. If you haven't noticed, that's still a lot of time spent in the office, and that's not including time spent commuting to/from work. The study also doesn't take into account all the paperwork and other aspects of being a doctor that are often done outside the office or from home. I believe that younger physicians are more tech-savvy and are more likely to utilize online resources and such from home.

The study correlates the decreased work hours with lower reimbursement rates in urban areas compared to rural areas. Let's address this. In urban areas there's often a "saturation" of primary care physicians. In more than one lunch or dinner panel with residents, some of them mentioned their concern over being (potentially) unable to find a job in an urban setting, and so sometimes decide to specialize. When you have more doctors in an area for a given population, each doctor sees fewer patients . . . and so likely works fewer hours. In contrast, rural areas have fewer doctors because fewer doctors want to practice there. And because there are fewer doctors, there's a greater need for them; thus, they work longer hours out of necessity to their patients and they well deserve to be reimbursed more for their increased work.

A point briefly mentioned in the study was the thought that younger physicians wish to have a more balanced lifestyle. As if that's a crime? . . . Is there something wrong to want to have time to spend with one's family and go to their children's events? Is there something wrong with wanting to take a vacation every now and then? Refer to the first point I made - that even with the reduction in work hours on average, it's still a lot of time at work. Times have changed since the 1970s. The rise of the two wage-earner family means that each wage-earner can afford to work fewer hours to support the family.

I remember reading a blog post on EverythingHealth by Dr. Toni Brayer called New Doctors - New Culture that hits at many of the points I've made. That post was written in 2008 and it continues to ring truer and truer every day. One of the top concerns of many of my female classmates is how to balance work with family - how can a doctor work so much and still be there for his/her kids? Something has to give.

So I ask: should the health of others be held above one's own health? Above the time one spends with one's own family and friends? Aren't doctors humans as well with very human needs and limits?

I think it's easy to forget that doctors are people too, that we're not all-knowing and unfeeling automatons. The reduction in work hours shouldn't be maligned, they should be welcomed as being more reasonable and more conducive to having a life outside the office. But certainly something has to be done to compensate those lost hours. The variables affecting the production of new doctors are complex and many (and I won't go into them here). But it all begins with a better health care system than currently exists in the US.

What do you do with guidelines?

Posted by Shari On 1/30/2010 03:22:00 PM 0 comments
Today, I'm going to write about something that came up on my infectious diseases rotation this month.

The Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) just published new guidelines for treating intra-abdominal infections. They came out at the beginning January. Apparently, there's been some debate in the ID world over whether these guidelines have too much industry influence. Several of the authors of the guidelines have connections with drug companies, and several of those drug companies happen to have recently come out with some very broad-spectrum, very expensive new antibiotics. These new antibiotics are part of the guidelines, and they are listed as options to treat intra-abdominal infections while some older, generic antibiotics were excluded because of concerns about resistance.

So there is debate and controversy over these new guidelines. The issue becomes a bit more complicated when you look at it from the hospital's perspective. We try to practice evidence-based medicine, as much as possible, and guidelines from major organizations like the IDSA are important tools in doing that, since they are essentially literature reviews. At a hospital like UM, the hospital's guidelines and policies might be based on the IDSA guidelines.

The question then becomes, if you are responsible for creating your hospital's antibiotic policies, what do you do with these guidelines? If you think there's too much industry bias, do you still base hospital policy on them? Do you ignore them? Do you just take the parts you think are unbiased and ignore the rest? And if you have to go through and figure out which parts are biased and which are not, how is that different than creating your own guidelines and ignoring the IDSA ones?

And if you have a patient with an intra-abdominal infection, and they die, and the patient's family thinks you should have used one of these newer, broad-spectrum antibiotics, then what? The patient's family/lawyers can point to the guidelines and say, look, here are national guidelines that say you could have used this drug. Why didn't you? Then you are left defending the tenuous position that national guidelines don't constitute standard of care.

And yet, if you really think that using the newer antibiotics will unnecessarily increase resistance and cost, you are ethically (and financially) obligated to restrict them.

It's a balance that each hospital has to find on its own. I think a big part of the answer is to look at resistance levels at your hospital, and to decide whether the older antibiotics will work in most cases or not. Cost, as always, is important as well.

In the end, guidelines are just that - guidelines. They shouldn't dictate policy on their own; there should be a significant amount of thought put into the value of the guidelines and of policy changes at a given hospital. That's why there are infectious disease specialty physicians and pharmacists.

The Importance of Translators

Posted by Alb On 1/24/2010 11:35:00 PM 2 comments

A middle-aged Chinese woman came to the clinic who spoke little English. As the only med student on staff that morning who could speak Mandarin Chinese, I was asked to help with the medical interview. While I wasn't obligated to offer translation help, it was a unique opportunity I couldn't pass up. As a result I've realized a few things:
---
1. Translating is very difficult.
Despite being fluent in (conversational) Mandarin, there were many questions I was unable to ask the patient directly. I knew how to say many common medical terms (e.g. hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes), but there were many more that I was simply unable to recall (e.g. cancer) even though I know the words. Furthermore, because I have no training in medical Chinese, there were many things I had to ask in a roundabout way - such as asking the patient if her condition worsened at particular times during her menstrual cycle (that was super awkward).

2. Translating is very time-consuming.
The work-up on that one patient took about 3 hours. Everything is at least doubled in time due to need to work through a translator (me). If I hadn't been available and willing, there was a translation service over the phone - but that might've been much worse, at least time-wise.

3. Knowing at least one other language is invaluable.
Because we live in an ever-increasingly global world, and particularly in the US as a very diverse country, the value of knowing multiple languages is indispensable, especially in the health care fields. Language still remains as a major barrier in delivering optimal medical care. A second language offers more than simply the ability to translate, as languages are almost invariable tied to cultures. As such, a language may offer some insight into cultural values that may prove very useful when treating a diverse patient population.

4. The rapport of the translator is important.
When there is a language barrier, the translator is potentially more important than the doctor. The patient looks to you, the translator, as the doctor's words. While a patient may give respectful deference to the doctor, they really look at you to speak the doctor's words and serve as his/her proxy in a sense. Therefore the demeanor and attitude of the translator is critical to ensure open and honest communication.
---
While ideally both doctor and patient speak the same language(s), this is not always possible (indeed, it rarely is). Heck, even if they do speak the same language(s) there may still be communication issues. It is equally unrealistic to require entering medical students to be proficient in more than one language. As such, the role of translators - preferably professional - is critical and often necessary.

Two Steps Forward?

Posted by Alb On 11/30/2009 07:45:00 PM 2 comments
As the health care bill is being debated in the US Senate, it's a good time for us going into/already in the health field to think about the next steps in US health care. I'd like to talk about 2 topics in this post: evidence-based medicine (EBM) and electronic medical records (EMR).
-----
Evidence-based medicine (EBM)

What is EBM? My personal definition of EBM is the application of science to the practice of clinical medicine. Sounds intuitive and obvious enough, and it sounds like all of medicine does/should operate this way, right? Apparently not.

To elaborate, EBM is the utilization of epidemiological studies (the study of disease patterns) and biostatistics to help physicians make more informed decisions when deciding on treatment or between two treatments, whether they be drugs, surgical intervention, or whatnot. Also, EBM allows for the ability to understand and critique the literature of medical studies in order for each physician to come to his/her own conclusions on the studies.

Arguably, a class on EBM is one of the most important courses a med student will take. It is also a class many med students loathe to take for various reasons - from their dislike of statistics, to the dry nature of the material, to the impersonal and "cold" methodology of analyzing data from many "anonymized" patients. This is perhaps best highlighted with the recent brouhaha in the news over changes in screening guidelines for breast cancer and Pap smears:


These revisions were generated in part by looking at and analyzing the current epidemiological data on those cancers. There is indeed a culture clash highlighted with these revisions - between those who dislike EBM and those who champion it. In my opinion, it would be wise to withhold final judgment on the new guidelines until one has read the study itself and decided if it's applicable to his/her practice.

Now, of course with all epidemiological studies the data is on pooling together a population (or populations) rather than focusing on a given individual. So while there is no "average patient," it's probably a good starting point. The guidelines don't apply to women with an above average risk of breast cancer or cervical cancer, i.e. a strong family history of breast cancer or testing positive for a BRCA1/2 allele variant.

Medicine is moving more and more towards EBM, as it should be. The more data we have, the more scientific knowledge we possess, the better we can develop guidelines and starting points when treating patients. But it should be noted that individuals are not a population, nor does a population represent an individual. EBM is a tool, and a very valuable one at that, but it shouldn't be the sole tool for a clinician.
-----
Electronic Medical Records (EMR)

There has been much excitement and distress over implementing EMR systems across hospitals in the US. Certainly EMRs have their advantages, but also less know are their current disadvantages. Suffice to say, EMR systems in the US are still nascent and may not quite ready for prime time.

The advantages of an EMR system are manifold. EMR reduces the amount of paperwork (save some trees!) which could aid in decreasing the possibility of paperwork becoming lost in the process. EMR has the advantage of being more easily organizable, such as creating tabs for "Medications," "Allergies," "Surgical History," "Family History," etc. Ultimately, EMR systems will be searchable (i.e. search for "allergy to penicillin") and more readily transferable between hospitals. So if I moved from Michigan to Wisconsin, a doctor in Wisconsin would be able to pull up my health records via EMR from Michigan once I've authorized it, rather than asking the hospital/clinic in Michigan for my health records to be faxed/sent over.

However, there are currently many obstacles to the final vision of EMR systems. My friend, Alicia, a genetic counseling student, went to their conference recently. And at their conference, there was a representative from a company that creates an EMR system. The representative painted a rather pessimistic outlook on EMRs.

One of the primary obstacles is that every hospital that uses EMRs use a different EMR system. Therefore these EMR systems aren't compatible with each other. So if a doctor in Wisconsin were to request my health records by EMR, his system has to first be compatible with the EMR system used in that hospital/clinic in Michigan. There's currently no communication between EMR systems and there appears to be little (if any) communication between the companies that design these systems - logically so, as they're competitors.

Another obstacle is the transition from paper to EMR. Someone has to either manually enter all the data into the EMR or scan the paperwork into the system. Both require considerable time and money. Paperwork can be easily buried, lost, or forgotten in the transition to EMR, potentially with devastating outcomes.

Lastly, there is some difficulty in making EMRs searchable. The cumulative medical/health data of a single individual from birth to death is enormous. EMRs would require a massive amount of storing capacity, and to design a search function that can find just what you want within that massive pile of data is currently out of reach. And a physician doesn't have the time (nor the patience probably) to look through a person's entire EMR to find that one relevant nugget of info.

So does this all mean that EMRs are doomed to fail? Not necessarily. There are obstacles, yes, but not insurmountable. If there was an incentive (perhaps from the federal government) for companies designing EMRs to communicate and collaborate, it's possible that a basic package that's compatible with all systems could be achieved. More specialized functions and widgets could be added on that need not necessarily be compatible with other EMR systems. There is also potentially a market niche in developing compatibility software that allows data from one EMR system to be accessed in another. The transition from paper to EMR is unavoidable, and it's just something that will have to take time and be toughed through (unless someone comes up with an ingenious method). And I've full confidence in the progress of technology to one day make EMRs searchable. I mean, look how far computers have advanced within the last 20 years!! But for the near future, making tabs for different clusters of data is probably the next best thing.

A nation-wide EMR system is currently a dream, and probably not something achievable within the next 20 years. But if there's a will there's a way, and being an optimist, I could see the potential and possibility of a nation-wide EMR system being in full use within the next 5-10 years. Where there's a will there's a way.

Lost in...Transitions

Posted by YO On 10/23/2009 08:17:00 PM 0 comments
In the endless quest for better technology and greater overall life expectancy, it almost feels as if the personal interaction with patients has been thrown lower and lower on providers' priority lists (in this country at least). Nowadays, the average American doctor spends less than 10 minutes actually talking to each patient. Meanwhile, the time a patient physically spends in the waiting room sometimes amounts to longer than the time it takes to roast a chicken.

Why is this important? Should we be concerned about the decline of the lifelong close relationship between a family and its chosen family doctor?

Yes, from a public health perspective, we should be concerned.

There are multiple angles from which to view this issue, but the one I'll discuss today is that of patients who are lost in the transitions going from one health care facility to another, or back home and then into the hospital again.

There are a lot of possible ways patients can get 'lost' in their health care environment. A simple example is migration. Patients who go from one state to another often find themselves in a new care facility every time they get sick. The last time I checked, the American system was still not very far in the mission to connect multiple health records of the same person. So each time patients walk into a clinic for the first time, they will have to explain themselves again. Which is not a problem if patients are knowledgeable about their own conditions, and keep good records or know their own drug regimens well. Alternatively, a lot of information can be missed.

But the health care providers often don't take it upon themselves to contact each other about particular patients, even among providers which are all separated by nothing more than a few miles. Is communication between the local STD clinic and the antenatal clinic and the district hospital necessary to care for a woman with a high-risk pregnancy? Is it the patients' responsibility to initiate such exchange of information? If so, are they aware of this??? Well, to tell you the truth......I don't know either.

Another interesting issue that I was made aware of recently is the problem of hospital re-admissions. Patients who are 1. admitted into hospitals, 2. treated, then 3. released--why is it that a large number of them (15~25% or so in Michigan) end up back in the hospital for the same condition they were supposedly treated for already?

One possible explanation (and only one of many) is that patients are not properly educated in the things they need to do when they get home from the hospital. They may be frightened from their prior event, don't understand well enough how to take care of themselves on their own, and/or are unable to promptly seek the right kind of help when they need it. Patients may find it difficult to approach health care providers with their questions (i.e. they are intimidated, don't feel rapport, don't feel like doctors and nurses mean anything they say, etc.), and often they will act like they understand the jumble of health jargon being thrown at them during visits...when in fact it's all going in one ear and out the next.

This raises some more concerns about health literacy in the general population. That's a topic I may or may not pick up in my next post...unfortunately, I don't know enough about it...yet.


Keep warm everyone!!

-----

Image: FreeDigitalPhotos.net

Additional reading on hospital readmissions:

Money, the thing that makes the world go 'round

Posted by Rui On 10/03/2009 11:30:00 PM 0 comments
Money, dollars, bills - those green pieces of paper with numbers and faces on them, are what's on everyone's mind these days, especially in the healthcare field. With the so-called economic crisis, resources are scarce in the medical community. I've heard many stories concerning the use of the emergency room as a way for patients to get over-the-counter meds, but I have never experienced it myself until my clinical preceptorships at the ED (emergency department). Now I realize how hard it is to be non-judgemental.

Many times I would see patients come in for conditions such as a common cold and ask to be prescribed tylenol or motrin. They would wait many hours in the waiting room with a fever and a cough, and use up not only medical resources but also their own precious time. When doing social histories, I'd ask patients whether they smoke or use alcohol. Oftentimes the answer to both is yes. With a pack of cigarettes costing $4 and alcohol being on a range of prices, people can end up spending a lot on these two amenities many consider essential in life. Being a non-smoker myself, I sometimes find it hard to be non-judgemental, for patients would spend on cigarettes yet not for medication for their condition.

After many such encounters, I talked with one of my preceptors about the situation. He responded that I can't be judgmental; if I grew up in similar situations as the patients, then the patient might be the 2nd-year medical student and I could be the smoker and alcoholic. I realized the importance of education, and what "don't judge the book by its cover" truly meant. With the healthcare in great need of reform, more attention should be placed on implementing earlier education in schools. Instead of the majority of attention being focused on where funds should be allocated or how to better manage the ED, funding should be placed in sexual education, health courses, and lifestyle-related courses in middle and high schools.

I don't know if what I'm advising is doable or valid, but I feel like it would be a step in the right direction in solving the healthcare crisis we are facing. Although this is easier said than done, with more attention placed in this field, perhaps we can shift our attention to better, more feasbile, and smarter methods in solving the education crisis.

Pharmacy Benefit Management Companies

Posted by Shari On 8/30/2009 05:25:00 PM 0 comments
This summer, I worked for the company everyone hates. Doctors, nurses, patients, pharmacists- everyone hates dealing with us and with the paperwork we create. I worked for a pharmacy benefits management company.

Those of you not in the pharmacy world might ask: What is a pharmacy benefits management company? The standard answer, which I always found extremely circular and frustrating, is that we manage pharmacy benefits for various insurance companies. In practice, it means that we are contracted by an insurance company to handle the everyday affairs of prescription claims. The patient takes a prescription to the pharmacy, they electronically bill the insurance company, and the insurance company's computer software automatically (according to a standard protocol) accepts or rejects the claim. When the pharmacy gets a rejection, either they or the doctor's office can call us, the PBM, to fight it. When the doctor's office sends in a prior authorization, we get it and we either make the decision, call the doctor's office for more information, or call and tell them it's been rejected.

We didn't have the final say in most cases, but we knew the general rules. No Nexium unless you've tried (and failed) Prilosec OTC. No Allegra unless you've failed Claritin. The list goes on. And so the doctors hated us because we were denying their patients meds that they felt were superior, and because we made them go search the patient's chart to find out whether they'd ever been on Claritin. And the pharmacies hated us because they had to tell the patients that their drug wasn't covered.

But with healthcare costs (especially prescription drug costs) spiralling higher and higher, insurance premiums rising, and the possibility of universal healthcare that would cost taxpayers however-many trillion dollars, there is clearly a role in healthcare for cost containment.

Let's take proton pump inhibitors (PPIs). We got a lot of prior authorizations for PPIs. Most of the insurance companies we worked for would approve Prilosec (omeprazole) with no problems. If you wanted to use a different PPI, you would have to show that the patient had used Prilosec and still had symptoms. To me, this was a reasonable rule. The efficacy rate of omeprazole is very similar to that of the other PPIs (such as rabeprazole, lansoprazole, pantoprazole, or esomeprazole). In fact, esomeprazole is just an isomer of omeprazole. They are essentially the same drug, except that esomeprazole is brand-name only (Nexium) and costs probably ten times as much. Doctors know this, or they should if they routinely prescribe PPIs. Yet we still got tons of requests for Nexium, or Protonix, or Aciphex for brand-new patients. Maybe a drug rep had given some samples to a doctor. Maybe the patient wasn't satisfied with something that was "just" an OTC drug and wanted something "better." There could be any number of reasons. I would call the doctor's office and ask if the patient had ever tried Prilosec. The nurse would say no, and I would say okay, they have to try Prilosec before we'll pay for anything else. And they would say okay, and a few hours later I would be able to check and see that the patient had filled a prescription for Prilosec.

So in that case, it makes sense to have someone regulating the transaction whose primary interest is economic. The insurance company saves money (sometimes over $100/month), the patient pays a lower copay, and insurance premiums nationwide go down (or at least don't go up).

Another benefit to PBMs is in catching medication errors (which, again, saves money). The best example of this is in Advair inhalers. There are two types of Advair inhalers- a traditional aerosol inhaler and a diskus. Unfortunately, the directions are different. The inhaler is taken as two puffs twice daily, and the diskus is taken as one inhalation twice daily. So when we saw a prescription for Advair diskus, two puffs twice daily, we knew that some doctor had confused the directions. We would call to get it fixed because the insurance company wouldn't want to pay for two inhalers in one month- but in the process, we saved a patient from overdosing on salmeterol and getting tachycardia or even a heart attack.

Of course, this isn't all-inclusive and won't catch everything, but it's always good for the system to have more checks.

The major problem with an insurance company or a PBM is the inherent conflict of interest. It was in our best interests to choose the lower-priced Prilosec over the equally-effective and higher-priced Protonix...but it was also in our best interests to choose a less effective but lower-priced drug over one that was more effective but higher-priced. And if there was ever a judgement call on a case, it almost always resulted in us rejecting the claim. Transdermal patches, for example, are really expensive in general, and we were very reluctant to cover them if there was an oral version available. A request for transdermal patches might be rejected solely because the patient had other oral meds in their profile and clearly was physically able to take drugs orally. Even a liquid version of a drug for a child might be questionable if the child was older than 6 or 7. There were times when I dreaded calling the doctor's office back, because I disagreed with the judgment that had been made and I knew that the doctor's office would too.

How can we get rid of this conflict of interest while still being cost-conscious? There is, obviously, no easy answer. Perhaps one of the best systems is what's used in hospitals, where a P&T committee, made up of the doctors who will be prescribing these drugs to their patients, is able to create the formulary for the entire hospital. This isn't very practical in the real world, unless we want to create groups of doctors who would also have a financial interest in an insurance company. (Which, of course, would create other conflicts of interest.) So I really don't know what the answer is. Educating patients and doctors helps, of course, and so does choosing conscientious pharmacists to work at PBMs. But that won't solve the problem entirely.

It's just one of the problems that will hopefully be addressed when our country's healthcare system is overhauled, over the next few years.